Multi-State Coalition Raises Antitrust Concerns on Sustainable Packaging Initiatives

Takeaways

• A multi-state coalition of 10 Republican Attorneys General has warned companies about joining sustainable packaging initiatives.
• The officials argue that participation in plastic reduction coalitions could raise antitrust concerns and lead to higher prices for consumers.
• The move marks the latest step in a broader anti-ESG campaign targeting climate-focused groups and companies.

A multi-state coalition of 10 U.S. Attorneys General has sent letters to nearly 80 companies, cautioning them against participating in sustainable packaging initiatives and environmental coalitions focused on plastic reduction.

The group, led by Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier, warned companies that continued coordination with certain environmental organizations could expose them to legal risks, including potential antitrust liability.

The announcement follows earlier letters sent in October to environmental groups such as the U.S. Plastics Pact, the Consumer Goods Forum, and the GreenBlue Institute. In those letters, state officials raised concerns that these groups were encouraging corporations to adopt uniform standards on plastic production and packaging.

Read More: Packaging Sustainability at a Crossroads: Setback or Shift?

According to the Attorneys General, coordinated action on sustainable packaging initiatives, such as setting recyclability targets or eliminating certain types of plastic, may reduce competition, raise consumer prices, and limit product choice. They argue that such efforts could potentially violate antitrust laws if companies align too closely on production or packaging standards.

The latest letters ask companies to clarify the legal basis for their participation in these environmental coalitions. The officials warned that failure to provide satisfactory explanations could lead to “formal investigative demands, subpoenas, or other compulsory legal processes.”

In a statement, Uthmeier said advocacy organizations have pressured companies into changing the output and quality of their goods in ways that normal market forces would not produce. He added that promoting a specific agenda does not exempt companies from complying with antitrust and consumer protection laws.

The letter was signed by Attorneys General from Florida, Georgia, Iowa, Kansas, Nebraska, North Dakota, South Dakota, Montana, Texas, and West Virginia.

Part of a Broader Anti-ESG Campaign

This action is part of a wider anti-ESG campaign by Republican officials who have increasingly targeted climate-focused alliances and their corporate members.

In 2024, several states filed lawsuits against major asset managers, including BlackRock, Vanguard, and State Street. The lawsuits alleged that these firms used their participation in climate initiatives like the Net Zero Asset Managers Initiative to influence energy markets. Following the legal pressure, each firm either exited or scaled back its involvement.

More recently, 23 state Attorneys General sent a letter to the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi), requesting detailed information about its activities and members. The officials cited possible violations of antitrust and consumer protection laws tied to participation in net-zero groups.

Also Read: The Future of Sustainable Packaging: Embracing Eco-Friendly Solutions

The growing scrutiny has created uncertainty for companies that have publicly committed to reducing plastic waste and lowering greenhouse gas emissions. Many firms joined sustainable packaging initiatives to meet investor expectations, respond to consumer demand, and address environmental risks.

However, with rising antitrust concerns and mounting political pressure, businesses now face a more complex landscape. Companies must weigh the reputational and environmental benefits of participating in sustainability coalitions against the possibility of regulatory investigations.

Follow more news and views via our Reporting & Standards and Featured Articles sections, and stay updated on the top ESG events to attend in 2026 for industry insights and networking.

If you're looking for suitable ESG and Sustainability providers to share customized solutions specific to your business needs, you can check out KnowESG's Solutions page.

If you are an ESG provider looking to get your organization listed on our portal, visit this page.

Source: ESGtoday